{ "source": { "source_id": "SRC-CONSCIOUSNESS-LIBRARY", "title": "The Consciousness Library", "source_type": "attributed research-discovery aggregator", "original_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/", "operator_as_stated": "Mindscape Collective", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-16", "classification": "RESEARCH_DISCOVERY_NOT_PRIMARY_EVIDENCE", "rights_status": "LINK_AND_METADATA_ONLY", "metadata_licence": "No blanket platform metadata or bulk-reuse licence verified; selected bibliographic facts independently checked at Crossref or original-publication records.", "reuse_boundary": "No abstracts, AI summaries, syntheses, full texts, images or database export imported. Attribution does not grant content rights.", "review_state": "AI_ASSISTED_SOURCE_CHECK_HUMAN_REVIEW_PENDING", "source_review_ref": "references/consciousness/consciousness-library-source-review-20261016.json", "claim_boundary": "Discovery and candidate links cannot change any Big Question conclusion.", "content_ingested": false, "truth_inference_allowed": false, "rights_promotion_allowed": false, "scientific_evidence_promotion_allowed": false, "canonical_identity_promotion_allowed": false, "public_synthesis_updated": false, "human_review_completed": false }, "review": { "schema_version": "0.1", "record_type": "discovery_source_due_diligence", "source_id": "SRC-CONSCIOUSNESS-LIBRARY", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "provenance": "ai-executed; user requested bounded source integration", "source_urls": { "home": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/", "methods": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/methods", "terms": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/terms", "pipeline": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/docs/article-pipeline.html", "research": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research", "contact": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/contact" }, "upstream_sources_as_stated": [ "PubMed", "Europe PMC", "OpenAlex", "Crossref", "Semantic Scholar", "Scopus", "Springer Nature", "DOAJ", "bioRxiv", "medRxiv", "arXiv", "PsyArXiv" ], "trials_source_as_stated": "ClinicalTrials.gov", "provenance_boundary": "The provider list describes the service. The importing provider for each selected library record is not exposed and remains null; independent verification providers are recorded separately.", "field_dictionary": [ { "fields": [ "title", "authors", "journal", "publication_date", "doi", "original_publication_url" ], "origin": "source-supplied bibliographic fields; verify independently" }, { "fields": [ "citation_count" ], "origin": "OpenAlex as stated; time-dependent; not used as evidence weight" }, { "fields": [ "study_design", "sample_size", "population", "intervention", "dose", "duration", "outcomes", "key_points" ], "origin": "AI extraction from abstract; not accepted without primary-source check" }, { "fields": [ "topic", "keyword", "related_record" ], "origin": "discovery labels; no equivalence or evidence promotion implied" }, { "fields": [ "synthesis", "evidence_rating" ], "origin": "automated synthesis/rating; no individual human synthesis review; excluded from import" } ], "deduplication_as_stated": "DOI and title matching; versions can be merged. AkashicNET separately preserves version and shared-study relationships.", "coverage": { "authoritative_min_publication_date": null, "authoritative_max_publication_date": null, "complete_historical_coverage_verified": false, "ui_year_min": 1900, "ui_year_max": 2027, "ui_note": "Observed input bounds only; not holdings endpoints or proof of completeness.", "observed_historical_record": { "discovery_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research/23251-mescaline-and-the-psychology-of-optic-hallucinations", "doi": "10.1097/00005053-191306000-00009", "title": "Mescaline and the Psychology of Optic Hallucinations", "crossref_publication_date": "1913-06", "library_display_date": "1913-06-01", "precision_note": "Crossref specifies month only; do not promote the displayed first day to a verified exact publication day." }, "observed_recent_record": { "discovery_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research/82540-the-perceptual-geometry-and-chromaticity-of-near-death", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1760389", "publication_date": "2026-10-15", "existing_site_record": "/data/spiritual-science-sources-2026-10-16.json#nde-geometry" }, "bounded_statement": "Observed dated records include 1913 and 2026. This is not an authoritative catalogue date range.", "queries": [ "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research?from_year=1900&to_year=1913", "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research?from_year=1900&sort=date_asc" ], "checks_not_completed": [ "complete pagination", "undated holdings", "pre-1900 holdings", "authoritative provider coverage declaration" ], "count_policy": "No catalogue total frozen into this integration; displayed counts vary with page and time." }, "reuse": { "terms_updated": "2026-07-15", "terms_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/terms", "platform_content_licence": "No open republication grant verified", "bulk_harvest_permission": "UNVERIFIED_NOT_ENABLED", "api_or_export_contract": "UNVERIFIED_NOT_ENABLED", "bibliographic_basis_url": "https://www.crossref.org/documentation/retrieve-metadata/", "permitted_in_this_update": [ "attributed source links", "independently verified bibliographic facts", "original AkashicNET candidate annotations" ], "excluded": [ "abstracts", "AI study cards", "AI syntheses", "full texts", "figures", "bulk catalogue extraction" ] }, "corrections": { "source_procedure": "Report the page URL and error to admin@consciousnesslibrary.org or the contact page. No message sent in this task.", "source_monitoring_as_stated": "Crossref notices and PubPeer counts; retracted records remain visible but are excluded from syntheses.", "akashicnet_procedure": [ "Retain original source identity and DOI.", "Record notice DOI, relationship, date and review scope separately.", "Preserve the previous assessment in version history.", "Require human review before changing evidence labels or model links." ], "critical_observation": "Crossref returned no update-to/updated-by for nsab052 although a primary erratum exists at nsab068. Empty update metadata is not a clean bill of health." }, "existing_work": { "github_main": "9cf967a7a9ed7921e6220189e46f4dc51c845a88", "sites_base": "33ee7ba3af8af69de5cbaeab9d586016dc27b79c", "existing_source_guide": "https://akashicnet.org/noetic-sciences/research-sources", "existing_record_count": 8, "earlier_context": "https://akashicnet.org/tsc2026/knowledge-commons", "decision": "Extend the existing source guide and add an AkashicLIBRARY pathway; preserve its existing records, including concurrent catalogue additions reconciled before publication." }, "selection_policy": "Three bounded examples spanning survival research, dream cognition and compassion. Two canonical works are reused; one new publication is staged. This is not a systematic review.", "bq_metadata_refs": [ "references/big-questions/BQ001/consciousness-library-discovery-20261016.json", "references/big-questions/BQ002/consciousness-library-discovery-20261016.json", "references/big-questions/BQ003/consciousness-library-discovery-20261016.json" ], "boundaries": { "content_ingested": false, "truth_inference_allowed": false, "rights_promotion_allowed": false, "scientific_evidence_promotion_allowed": false, "canonical_identity_promotion_allowed": false, "public_synthesis_updated": false, "human_review_completed": false }, "remaining_human_review": [ "source registration and reuse scope", "BQ003 candidate study appraisal", "any future evidence promotion" ], "automation_changed": false }, "records": [ { "question_id": "BQ001", "source_id": "SRC-BQ001-AWARE-2014", "operation": "ADD_DISCOVERY_PROVENANCE_TO_EXISTING_WORK", "existing_record_ref": "references/big-questions/BQ001/evidence-batch1-v0.1.json#SRC-BQ001-AWARE-2014", "title": "AWARE-AWAreness during REsuscitation-a prospective study", "authors_short": "Parnia et al.", "doi": "10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004", "year": 2014, "journal": "Resuscitation", "original_url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004", "verification_url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25301715/", "discovery_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research/78768-aware-awareness-during-resuscitation-a-prospective-study", "dates": { "online": "2014-10-07", "issue": "2014-12", "library_display": "2014-10-07" }, "design": "Multicentre prospective observational study", "scope_note": "2060 cardiac-arrest events; 140 first-stage and 101 second-stage interviews. Relevant to how experience reports can be tested during resuscitation.", "limitations": "Survivor selection and retrospective recall limit timing inferences. Cardiac arrest during attempted resuscitation is not irreversible death.", "bq_contribution": "Reuse the existing BQ001 baseline and its limitations; the discovery link adds no independent study.", "verification_depth": "PubMed bibliographic record and author abstract checked; existing canonical assessment retained. Crossref request rate-limited; no successful Crossref check claimed.", "correction_check": { "status": "BOUNDED_CHECK_NO_RETRACTION_NOTICE_OBSERVED", "basis": "PubMed comments inspected; no new full-text/Crossmark audit. Prior repository audit is dated 2026-09-23.", "human_review_required": true }, "deduplication": { "method": "case-folded DOI plus NFKC alphanumeric title over tracked text files", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "matches": { "github": [ "docs/audits/manual-corpus-reading-2026-09-22.md", "references/big-questions/BQ001/evidence-batch1-v0.1.json", "references/big-questions/BQ001/source-integrity-batch6-review-v0.1.json", "references/community/bq001-scientific-baseline-batch1.json", "references/community/public-safe-semantic-endpoint-registry-v0.1.9.json", "references/source-integrity-v014-assessment-batch1-review-v0.1.json" ], "sites": [ "public/data/bq001-near-death-primary-source-ledger-v0.1.0.json", "public/research/source-catalogue/index.html", "public/research/source-catalogue/records.json" ] }, "independence_key": "doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2014.09.004", "new_independent_evidence_count": 0, "title_similarity_auto_merge": false }, "discovery_source_id": "SRC-CONSCIOUSNESS-LIBRARY", "library_importing_provider": null, "question_status": "UNRESOLVED", "relationship_status": "HUMAN_REVIEW_PENDING", "evidence_label_changed": false, "supports_models": [], "rights": { "scope": "BIBLIOGRAPHIC_METADATA_AND_ORIGINAL_REVIEW_NOTES", "abstract_copied": false, "full_text_republished": false, "ai_summary_copied": false, "bulk_harvest": false }, "boundaries": { "content_ingested": false, "truth_inference_allowed": false, "rights_promotion_allowed": false, "scientific_evidence_promotion_allowed": false, "canonical_identity_promotion_allowed": false, "public_synthesis_updated": false, "human_review_completed": false } }, { "question_id": "BQ002", "source_id": "SRC-BQ002-HUDACHEK-WAMSLEY-2023", "operation": "ADD_DISCOVERY_PROVENANCE_TO_EXISTING_WORK", "existing_record_ref": "references/big-questions/BQ002/evidence-batch1-review-candidates-v0.1.json#SRC-BQ002-HUDACHEK-WAMSLEY-2023", "title": "A meta-analysis of the relation between dream content and memory consolidation", "authors_short": "Hudachek and Wamsley", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsad111", "year": 2023, "journal": "SLEEP", "original_url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsad111", "verification_url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37058584/", "discovery_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research/45603-a-meta-analysis-of-the-relation-between-dream-content-and", "dates": { "crossref_online": "2023-04-14", "crossref_print": "2023-12-11", "library_display": "2023-12-11", "europe_pmc_issue": "2023-12", "europe_pmc_firstPublicationDate": "2023-12-01", "note": "Different date events/precision retained; do not infer earliest online publication from Europe PMC issue metadata." }, "design": "Meta-analysis", "scope_note": "16 studies and 45 effects associate learning-related dream content with post-sleep memory performance.", "limitations": "Association does not establish causation or explain all thought. Sleep-stage differences are preliminary and should not be inferred simply from different subgroup significance.", "bq_contribution": "Reuse the existing BQ002 review candidate as a bounded memory-related route into thought content.", "verification_depth": "Crossref metadata plus the author abstract and Comment-in relation via Europe PMC checked; full-text and raw-data appraisal remain pending.", "correction_check": { "status": "BOUNDED_CHECK_NO_RETRACTION_NOTICE_OBSERVED", "comment_doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsad139", "basis": "Europe PMC Comment-in relation; Crossref update fields empty. Commentary is not a correction or independent replication.", "human_review_required": true }, "deduplication": { "method": "case-folded DOI plus NFKC alphanumeric title over tracked text files", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "matches": { "github": [ "references/big-questions/BQ002/evidence-batch1-review-candidates-v0.1.json" ], "sites": [] }, "independence_key": "doi:10.1093/sleep/zsad111", "new_independent_evidence_count": 0, "title_similarity_auto_merge": false }, "discovery_source_id": "SRC-CONSCIOUSNESS-LIBRARY", "library_importing_provider": null, "question_status": "UNRESOLVED", "relationship_status": "HUMAN_REVIEW_PENDING", "evidence_label_changed": false, "supports_models": [], "rights": { "scope": "BIBLIOGRAPHIC_METADATA_AND_ORIGINAL_REVIEW_NOTES", "abstract_copied": false, "full_text_republished": false, "ai_summary_copied": false, "bulk_harvest": false }, "boundaries": { "content_ingested": false, "truth_inference_allowed": false, "rights_promotion_allowed": false, "scientific_evidence_promotion_allowed": false, "canonical_identity_promotion_allowed": false, "public_synthesis_updated": false, "human_review_completed": false }, "metadata_verification": { "provider": "Crossref", "url": "https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1093/sleep/zsad111", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "title": "A meta-analysis of the relation between dream content and memory consolidation", "authors": [ "Lauren Hudachek", "Erin J Wamsley" ], "publication_dates": { "published": { "date-parts": [ [ 2023, 4, 14 ] ] }, "published-online": { "date-parts": [ [ 2023, 4, 14 ] ] }, "published-print": { "date-parts": [ [ 2023, 12, 11 ] ] } }, "relation": {} } }, { "question_id": "BQ003", "source_id": "SRC-BQ003-ASHAR-2021-COMPASSION", "operation": "STAGE_NEW_REVIEW_CANDIDATE", "existing_record_ref": null, "title": "Effects of compassion training on brain responses to suffering others", "authors_short": "Ashar et al.", "doi": "10.1093/scan/nsab052", "year": 2021, "journal": "Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience", "original_url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsab052", "verification_url": "https://academic.oup.com/scan/article/16/10/1036/6265002", "discovery_url": "https://consciousnesslibrary.org/research/49312-effects-of-compassion-training-on-brain-responses-to", "dates": { "publisher_online": "2021-05-05", "crossref_online": "2021-05-05", "crossref_print": "2021-09-30", "library_display": "2021-09-30", "publisher_issue": "2021-10", "publisher_corrected_and_typeset": "2021-09-28", "note": "Retain distinct online, typesetting and issue events; displayed dates are not interchangeable." }, "design": "Three-arm randomised trial with longitudinal fMRI", "scope_note": "57 adults; four weeks of compassion meditation compared with a familiarity control and a placebo framed as oxytocin.", "limitations": "The medial orbitofrontal result survived correction versus familiarity; the placebo comparison was reported only at an uncorrected threshold. Small sample and short follow-up limit generalisation.", "bq_contribution": "Candidate for personal regulation and neural mechanisms of compassion. Does not test a cosmic love field, nonlocal access or survival.", "verification_depth": "Publisher bibliographic information and abstract, Crossref version relation, and full erratum text checked; full-paper critical appraisal and independent replication review pending.", "correction_check": { "status": "TITLE_ERRATUM_VERIFIED", "notice_doi": "10.1093/scan/nsab068", "notice_url": "https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsab068", "verified_text_url": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC8483276/fullTextXML", "notice_online_date": "2021-06-12", "scope": "Title changed from singular other to plural others; no results correction stated in this notice.", "human_review_required": true }, "version_relationships": [ { "relation": "has_preprint", "doi": "10.1101/616029", "basis": "Crossref relation", "independent_replication": false } ], "question_registration_status": "REVIEW_CANDIDATE", "public_beta_gate_changed": false, "deduplication": { "method": "case-folded DOI plus NFKC alphanumeric title over tracked text files", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "matches": { "github": [], "sites": [] }, "independence_key": "doi:10.1093/scan/nsab052", "new_independent_evidence_count": 0, "title_similarity_auto_merge": false }, "discovery_source_id": "SRC-CONSCIOUSNESS-LIBRARY", "library_importing_provider": null, "question_status": "UNRESOLVED", "relationship_status": "HUMAN_REVIEW_PENDING", "evidence_label_changed": false, "supports_models": [], "rights": { "scope": "BIBLIOGRAPHIC_METADATA_AND_ORIGINAL_REVIEW_NOTES", "abstract_copied": false, "full_text_republished": false, "ai_summary_copied": false, "bulk_harvest": false }, "boundaries": { "content_ingested": false, "truth_inference_allowed": false, "rights_promotion_allowed": false, "scientific_evidence_promotion_allowed": false, "canonical_identity_promotion_allowed": false, "public_synthesis_updated": false, "human_review_completed": false }, "metadata_verification": { "provider": "Crossref", "url": "https://api.crossref.org/works/10.1093/scan/nsab052", "checked_on": "2026-10-16", "title": "Effects of compassion training on brain responses to suffering others", "authors": [ "Yoni K Ashar", "Jessica R Andrews-Hanna", "Joan Halifax", "Sona Dimidjian", "Tor D Wager" ], "publication_dates": { "published": { "date-parts": [ [ 2021, 5, 5 ] ] }, "published-online": { "date-parts": [ [ 2021, 5, 5 ] ] }, "published-print": { "date-parts": [ [ 2021, 9, 30 ] ] } }, "relation": { "has-preprint": [ { "id-type": "doi", "id": "10.1101/616029", "asserted-by": "object" } ] } } } ] }