{"title":"HIERATIC018: Intention, Habit and Accountability Review","checked":"2026-10-31","date_timezone":"Europe/Berlin","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED","provenance":"ai-executed; user-directed","publication_status":"Complete working edition awaiting editorial approval; 3 November 2026, Europe/Berlin is a provisional target conditional on readiness. No automatic release.","scope":"Selected primary-source reading and editorial integration; not a systematic review or raw-data reanalysis.","chapter":"/previews/hieratic-book-ii/hieratic018","records":[{"id":"WEBB-SHEERAN-2006","doi":"10.1037/0033-2909.132.2.249","url":"https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.2.249","inspected_url":"https://phe512.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/04-webb.pdf","version":"Published main paper, selected sections","sections":["selection criteria","pooled results","discussion pp. 260–262"],"status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"SHEERAN-LISTROM-GOLLWITZER-2024","doi":"10.1080/10463283.2024.2334563","url":"https://doi.org/10.1080/10463283.2024.2334563","inspected_url":"https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Paschal-Sheeran/publication/378870694_The_When_and_How_of_Planning_Meta-Analysis_of_the_Scope_and_Components_of_Implementation_Intentions_in_642_Tests/links/65f06a571f0aec67e282f88a/The-When-and-How-of-Planning-Meta-Analysis-of-the-Scope-and-Components-of-Implementation-Intentions-in-642-Tests.pdf","version":"Author accepted manuscript; publisher abstract also checked","sections":["methods","analysis strategy and bias sensitivity","results","generality constraints"],"remaining":"Reconcile final published version and supplementary coding; no statistical reproduction.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"LALLY-2010","doi":"10.1002/ejsp.674","url":"https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.674","inspected_url":"https://www.flexyourbrain.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/UL-STUDY-66-Days-IJSP_998-1009.pdf","version":"Published main paper; 2010 issue, 2009 copyright","sections":["methods","sample flow","Table 2","discussion"],"status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"PICKARD-2011","doi":"10.1353/ppp.2011.0032","url":"https://doi.org/10.1353/ppp.2011.0032","inspected_url":"https://www.hannapickard.com/uploads/3/1/5/5/31550141/06_18.3pickard_2.pdf","version":"Author-hosted published paper","role":"Philosophical and clinical argument, not a trial","sections":["conceptual distinctions","detached and affective blame","clinical application"],"status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"}],"existing_compassion_review":{"pr":"https://github.com/tws9stmcbf-web/AkashicNET/pull/394","head_sha":"c2262f8df8e800478e3f7abfd5407cbc9069173a","source_record":"/data/hieratic018-training-evidence-20261028.json","action":"Retain six appraisals; add selected numerical clarification after primary-paper rechecks.","studies":["CM-LEAD-011","CM-LEAD-012","CM-LEAD-013","CM-LEAD-014","CM-LEAD-015","CM-LEAD-016"]},"remaining_review":["Independent risk-of-bias, registration and correction audit","Review and cohort overlap reconciliation","Raw-data and code verification","Direct evidence of sustained everyday helping and recipient outcomes","Tradition-specific human review"],"boundaries":["No supernatural or post-death karmic mechanism established","Normative responsibility framing is not derived from pooled effects","No inference that suffering is deserved","No accepted BQ evidence or maturity levels changed","No new independent experiment or replication counted"],"editorial_revision":{"date":"2026-11-01","action":"Consolidated narrative; corrected superseded 2 November target to 3 November. Original 31 October source reading scopes and REVIEW_REQUIRED statuses retained."}}