{"title":"HIERATIC018: Training, Intention and Observable Action","checked":"2026-10-28","date_timezone":"America/Los_Angeles","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED","provenance":"ai-executed; user-directed scope","discovery_pr":"https://github.com/tws9stmcbf-web/AkashicNET/pull/394","catalogue_commit":"c2262f8df8e800478e3f7abfd5407cbc9069173a","catalogue_path":"references/research/psi-ions-catalogue-2026-10-02/compassion-prosocial-batch.json","scope":"Selected primary-publication methods, results and limitations; selected Weng and Condon supplementary methods; review comparison. Not a systematic search, completed risk-of-bias assessment or data reanalysis.","independent_studies_promoted":0,"canonical_bq_evidence_status_changed":false,"records":[{"id":"CM-LEAD-012","citation":"Weng and colleagues · 2013","title":"Compassion Training Alters Altruism and Neural Responses to Suffering","doi":"10.1177/0956797612469537","url":"https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797612469537","inspected_url":"https://cbrt.nalandainstitute.org/pdfs/weng-2013-compassion-training-alters-altruism.pdf","role":"randomised training experiment","measured":"Costly monetary redistribution after two weeks of compassion or cognitive-reappraisal training. Compassion trainees redistributed more in the analysed sample. Compassion versus reappraisal: reported d = 0.65 (post-training comparison).","limits":"41 of 56 protocol completers were analysed (20 compassion, 21 reappraisal); 15 who doubted the simulated players were excluded. Behaviour was measured only after training, so this is a group difference, not a measured within-person increase. A single game does not establish lasting everyday helping.","reading_scope":"Main paper Methods, Results and limitations; selected supplementary task and sample-selection descriptions. No raw-data, imaging or code reanalysis. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"CM-LEAD-013","citation":"Condon and colleagues · 2013","title":"Meditation Increases Compassionate Responses to Suffering","doi":"10.1177/0956797613485603","url":"https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797613485603","inspected_url":"https://paulcondon.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/condon-et-al-2013-meditation-increases-compassion.pdf","role":"randomised waitlist experiment","measured":"After eight weeks, 10/20 meditators offered a seat to a person apparently in pain, versus 3/19 waitlist controls. Confederates were blind to condition and hypothesis. These rates were 50.0% versus 15.8%; reported odds ratio = 5.33, not a fivefold probability of helping.","limits":"67 people were recruited; 26 dropped out and two were excluded, leaving 39 analysed. Mindfulness and compassion groups were pooled, with no detected difference between them. The waitlist did not match class or teacher contact. One staged encounter cannot demonstrate a lasting habit.","reading_scope":"Author-hosted main paper and selected appended supplementary recruitment, exclusions and control-group limitations. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"CM-LEAD-011","citation":"Leiberg, Klimecki and Singer · 2011","title":"Short-Term Compassion Training Increases Prosocial Behavior in a Newly Developed Prosocial Game","doi":"10.1371/journal.pone.0017798","url":"https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0017798","inspected_url":"https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0017798","role":"nonrandomised controlled training study","measured":"The reported game-helping increase was greater than with memory training (time-by-training interaction p = .05), tested two to five days after a workshop. Reported compassionate feelings also increased; dictator-game giving did not change in either group. The time-by-training interaction had partial eta-squared = 0.07.","limits":"Allocation depended on available slots and participants’ timing, not randomisation. Of 69 women entering, 60 completed and one lacked game data (59 analysed). Selection, attrition and the short laboratory follow-up constrain causal and everyday-behaviour claims.","reading_scope":"Publisher main paper: Experiment 2 allocation and flow, outcome measures, results and discussion. Supplementary datasets not analysed. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"CM-LEAD-014","citation":"Ashar and colleagues · 2016","title":"Effects of Compassion Meditation on a Psychological Model of Charitable Donation","doi":"10.1037/emo0000119","url":"https://doi.org/10.1037/emo0000119","inspected_url":"https://www.talyarkoni.org/pdf/Ashar_Emotion_2016.pdf","role":"donation-model development and randomised training trial","measured":"Study 2 randomised 58 people to four weeks of compassion meditation, placebo oxytocin or familiarity training. Real-money donation choices and self-reported feelings and attributions were separate outcomes. Table 2 donation-change contrasts: compassion versus familiarity +$8.17 (95% CI $2.22–$14.11); versus placebo +$5.95 (−$2.33–$14.23); versus pooled controls +$7.06 ($1.34–$12.78).","limits":"Donation change differed from familiarity and pooled controls, but not placebo oxytocin alone. Compassion’s within-group donation increase was nonsignificant; familiarity donations declined. Psychological scores improved against placebo without demonstrating a significant donation-change advantage. Post-intervention assessors were unblinded; one donation-task exclusion is reported and outcome denominators vary. Lasting change is unestablished. These are differences in change in dollars per donation trial, not standardised compassion effects or within-group gains.","reading_scope":"Author-hosted main paper, especially Study 2 Methods and Results, Tables 1–2 and limitations. Supplementary data and any later cohort reports not reanalysed or counted separately. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"CM-LEAD-015","citation":"Kreplin, Farias and Brazil · 2018","title":"The Limited Prosocial Effects of Meditation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis","doi":"10.1038/s41598-018-20299-z","url":"https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-20299-z","inspected_url":"https://pure.coventry.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/13380050/The_limited_prosocial_effects_of_meditation.pdf","role":"systematic review and meta-analysis","measured":"In healthy-adult randomised studies, pooled benefits concerned compassion and empathy, not all prosocial categories. Most study quality was graded weak. The compassion subgroup was significant against passive controls but not active controls. Overall Pearson’s r = 0.26 (95% CI 0.18–0.34); compassion active-control estimate r = 0.37 (−0.04–0.78).","limits":"Similar active/passive point estimates and wide intervals do not establish a difference between control types. Outcomes included questionnaires and behavioural tasks. The review’s Pearson-r estimates are not directly comparable with Luberto’s standardised mean differences; neither is a new experiment.","reading_scope":"University-deposited published paper: eligibility, results, quality assessment, Table 3 and discussion. Full supplementary study-level overlap/coding audit pending. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"},{"id":"CM-LEAD-016","citation":"Luberto and colleagues · online 2017; 2018 issue","title":"A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of the Effects of Meditation on Empathy, Compassion, and Prosocial Behaviors","doi":"10.1007/s12671-017-0841-8","url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s12671-017-0841-8","inspected_urls":["https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12671-017-0841-8","https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6081743/"],"role":"systematic review and meta-analysis","measured":"26 trials with 1,714 participants; separate pooled effects for self-report (SMD 0.40) and observable outcomes (SMD 0.45), with benefits also reported in active-control subgroups. Observable-outcome SMD 0.45 had 95% CI 0.28–0.61.","limits":"Eligibility included children and clinical populations and excluded studies measuring only self-compassion, unlike Kreplin’s scope. Meta-analysis focused on immediate effects; only four studies included longer follow-up. Different inclusion and outcome coding require reconciliation; review totals must not be added to primary-trial counts. Observable outcomes included tasks and ratings beyond direct helping; they do not all measure recipient benefit.","reading_scope":"Publisher abstract, dates and bibliography; selected PMC manuscript eligibility, synthesis methods, study characteristics and risk-of-bias results. Statistical synthesis not reproduced. Selected numerical results rechecked 31 October 2026; no reanalysis.","status":"REVIEW_REQUIRED"}],"relationships":[{"records":["CM-LEAD-015","CM-LEAD-016"],"relation":"reviews_of_overlapping_literature_not_independent_experimental_replications","note":"Both bibliographies cite Condon 2013 and Weng 2013. A complete included-study, outcome and cohort-overlap audit remains unfinished. No participant totals are combined here."}],"remaining_review":["Independent methodological review, including selection, attrition, allocation concealment, blinding and multiplicity","Complete trial/cohort overlap and outcome-coding comparison between reviews","Direct evidence for habit formation, automaticity and sustained everyday helping","Raw-data and code verification, registration and correction checks"],"interpretive_boundary":"These publications investigate psychological training and social behaviour, not religious karmic causation or moral deservingness. No result licenses victim blaming or inference that illness, disability, poverty, abuse or bereavement is deserved.","effect_size_recheck":"2026-10-31","effect_size_recheck_timezone":"Europe/Berlin"}