{"id":"NEXUS-AUDIT-ENHANCE-2026-11-19","recorded_at":"2026-11-19T15:10:41.603865+00:00","component":"AkashicAUDIT","method":"AkashicENHANCE documented guidance applied by implementing assistant","scope":"Public definition and copyable checklist only","reviewer_role":"Implementing assistant; self-review, not independent","before_version":"v0.1.0-draft.2","after_version":"v0.1.0-draft.3","findings":[{"id":"AUDIT-ENH-001","before":"Coverage not explicitly required","after":"Require reviewed edition, selection method, eligible/reviewed/excluded items and exclusion reasons","severity":"Moderate: guidance ambiguity","confidence":"Reasoned editorial assessment; not measured effectiveness","implementation_state":"Implemented in guidance; runtime workflow remains planned","affected_claim_ids":[],"affected_record":"AkashicAUDIT public definition and prompt","recheck_type":"Wording and structural consistency","recheck_method":"Check updated HTML prompt exactly matches canonical definition, version consistency and unchanged pilot bytes"},{"id":"AUDIT-ENH-002","before":"Correction and recheck requested without explicit closure rule","after":"Add finding lifecycle and require passing recheck evidence on revised edition before closure","severity":"Moderate: guidance ambiguity","confidence":"Reasoned editorial assessment; not measured effectiveness","implementation_state":"Implemented in guidance; runtime workflow remains planned","affected_claim_ids":[],"affected_record":"AkashicAUDIT public definition and prompt","recheck_type":"Wording and structural consistency","recheck_method":"Check updated HTML prompt exactly matches canonical definition, version consistency and unchanged pilot bytes"},{"id":"AUDIT-ENH-003","before":"Independent reviewer distinction present but disagreements lack handling","after":"Preserve competing rationales and adjudication; retain author overlap disclosure","severity":"Moderate: guidance ambiguity","confidence":"Reasoned editorial assessment; not measured effectiveness","implementation_state":"Implemented in guidance; runtime workflow remains planned","affected_claim_ids":[],"affected_record":"AkashicAUDIT public definition and prompt","recheck_type":"Wording and structural consistency","recheck_method":"Check updated HTML prompt exactly matches canonical definition, version consistency and unchanged pilot bytes"},{"id":"AUDIT-ENH-004","before":"Severity requested without separate confidence or decision ownership","after":"Separate severity and confidence; name action and risk decision owners","severity":"Moderate: guidance ambiguity","confidence":"Reasoned editorial assessment; not measured effectiveness","implementation_state":"Implemented in guidance; runtime workflow remains planned","affected_claim_ids":[],"affected_record":"AkashicAUDIT public definition and prompt","recheck_type":"Wording and structural consistency","recheck_method":"Check updated HTML prompt exactly matches canonical definition, version consistency and unchanged pilot bytes"}],"before_prompt":"Use this planned AkashicAUDIT checklist. Record the scope, criteria, reviewer role and authorised audience. Link each finding to a source, claim or check record. Separate passed, failed, untested and reasoned not-applicable checks. Record severity with reasons, a proposed correction and the method for rechecking it. State whether review was by the original author or an independent reviewer. Keep Restricted and HOLD material within its existing audience. Return findings, evidence, changes needed and open questions. For each material claim, compare it with the exact source excerpt and choose supported, partly supported, contradicted or unresolved, with a reason. Split compound claims and check numbers, dates, population, qualifiers and causal language. Record evidence availability separately; absent or irrelevant evidence does not establish falsity. Include a check ID, exact source pointer, expected and observed result where a test has a declared expectation, observation timestamp, reviewer role and scope limits. Preserve the prior decision when revising it.","after_prompt":"Use this planned AkashicAUDIT checklist. Record the scope, criteria, reviewer role and authorised audience. Link each finding to a source, claim or check record. Separate passed, failed, untested and reasoned not-applicable checks. Record severity with reasons, a proposed correction and the method for rechecking it. State whether review was by the original author or an independent reviewer. Keep Restricted and HOLD material within its existing audience. Return findings, evidence, changes needed and open questions. For each material claim, compare it with the exact source excerpt and choose supported, partly supported, contradicted or unresolved, with a reason. Split compound claims and check numbers, dates, population, qualifiers and causal language. Record evidence availability separately; absent or irrelevant evidence does not establish falsity. Include a check ID, exact source pointer, expected and observed result where a test has a declared expectation, observation timestamp, reviewer role and scope limits. Preserve the prior decision when revising it. Declare the reviewed edition, selection method and coverage: eligible, reviewed and excluded items with exclusion reasons. Do not imply unreviewed items passed. Give findings stable IDs and keep severity separate from confidence. Use open, correction proposed, awaiting recheck, closed or accepted risk states. Close only after the declared recheck passes on the revised edition and evidence is linked. An accepted risk remains distinct from a passed check; name the decision owner and reason. Preserve disagreements, both rationales and any adjudication; original-author review is never independent validation. Record what each check can establish and its limits. Escalate inaccessible evidence or unresolved material contradictions to a publication decision, preserving HOLD until the authorised decision owner resolves it. Public summaries use public evidence only; keep restricted source metadata within its authorised boundary.","baseline_page_sha256":"d68501897f2533d3ac31ef0a9329c0dcb2a42fd75eefb2ece4a2d54019e7ac21","prior_pilot_sha256":{"data/nexus-audit-ledger-pilot-001.json":"4c106be6dead91f58bc831aed87ddf3896ef74b1dd2c710ee8628e746472f040","data/nexus-audit-ledger-pilot-002.json":"d250a6dc32d7e3f50b822aaec29268d1bbfeb4a7ffd14558750f43e2755e6158","data/nexus-audit-ledger-pilot-003.json":"7ebeb02a07d8fcbcb1ffa170d99de2b81aa7af5e80e56c71bc8b5d5136d371e7"},"checks":[{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"prompt_matches_definition","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"edition_matches","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"public_definition_mirror","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"prior_pilots_unchanged","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"unassessed_retained","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Wording and structural consistency","name":"new_record_link_exists","result":"Passed","scope_limit":"Does not establish effectiveness, browser behaviour or operational enforcement"},{"type":"Site route, anchor and asset audit","method":"node scripts/audit-public-site.mjs","result":"Passed after checksum-verified recovery of pre-existing staged video","scope_limit":"Existing incoming-link discovery warnings remain; no browser or effectiveness claim"}],"state_decision":{"readiness":"Unassessed","score":null,"release_stage":"Planned · Definition Draft","basis":"Guidance improvements do not establish operational reliability or independent effectiveness"},"remaining_uncertainty":["No independent comparison","No representative effectiveness evaluation","No runtime enforcement, durable operational store or access-control test"],"ledger_events":[{"id":"AUDIT-ENH-E001","event_date":"2026-11-19T15:10:41.603865+00:00","logging_date":"2026-11-19T15:10:41.603865+00:00","type":"Guidance revision","earlier_record":"/data/nexus-audit-ledger-pilot-003.json","before":"v0.1.0-draft.2","after":"v0.1.0-draft.3","audience":"Public editorial record only","reviewer_role":"Implementing assistant","unresolved":"Independent review and operational implementation pending"}],"publication_status":"Prepared; deployment receipt not yet recorded"}