# Worked Claim Review · Counting Scenes and Participants

**Record OMNI-W01 · v1 · 11 November 2026**

Method: [AkashicOMNI v0.5.0 Public Review Specification](https://akashicnet.org/akashicomni/v0-5-0#process). Scoped manual example for the [Researcher Starter Kit](https://akashicnet.org/akashicomni/research-kit#start). AI-assisted teaching record. Independent methodological review pending.

## 1 · Claim and Question

**Teaching claim:** The 108 classified scenes in the Lerner study are 108 independent participant observations. This is a test proposition for the exercise.

**Question:** What did the study count, and does each counted scene come from a different person?

Scope: check the reported sample and analysis unit, then trace the coverage to the underlying study. The origin of the experiences and the validity of the full study are outside this exercise.

## 2 · Source Register

| ID | Source and passage inspected | Access and dependency |
| --- | --- | --- |
| S1 | Lerner et al. (2026), [The perceptual geometry and chromaticity of near-death experience spaces](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13716671/), Methods, Results and Table 1 | Relevant passages from the full article accessed 11 November 2026. Primary study, DOI `10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1760389`. |
| S2 | [ScienceAlert coverage](https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-asked-50-people-to-map-their-near-death-experiences-an-eerie-pattern-emerged), sample, reconstruction procedure and colour counts | Public article accessed 11 November 2026. Reports S1. |
| S3 | AkashicNET, [Mapping Near-Death Experiences](https://akashicnet.org/continuity-research/nde-mapping), reconstruction and scene counts | Public appraisal accessed 11 November 2026. Synthesises S1 and contextual studies. This claim uses the S1 portion. |

Treat S1, S2 and the relevant part of S3 as one study group for this claim. S2 and S3 can help locate or explain the primary evidence.

## 3 · DISCERN

- 50 participants reconstructed 112 experiential parts. The four predefined visual-field categories include 108 of those parts. Three parts fell under “Other Space” and one under “No Space”. [S1]
- The table counts reconstructed scenes. Table 1 shows that many people contributed more than one scene. [S1]
- The paper reports a separate analysis that accounts for scenes from the same participant. Keep that analysis distinct from the scene counts. [S1, S3]

## 4 · DEEPEN

- A single scene is a useful unit for describing shape or colour. Multiple scenes from one person can share that person’s recall, reporting style and session conditions. The count of scenes therefore answers a different question from the count of participants. [S1]
- Guided reconstruction, pictogram choices and the absence of a comparison group matter when interpreting the shape–colour association. They motivate the linked gap card. [S1, S3]
- The study counts and excerpts are sufficient for checking the reported denominator. Participant-level inputs and analytic code would be needed for a reproduction of the clustered analysis.

## 5 · Perspective Coverage

Scoped reading. AWAKEN distinguishes source observation from inference. #METAD identifies the assumption of independence. CUT Present records the count trail and CUT Future identifies a possible discriminating follow-up. The other public roles were outside this methods exercise. A full reading would record each disposition separately.

## 6 · Synthesis

The study’s reported 108 is a count of classified scenes. The original sample comprised 50 people, some of whom contributed several scenes. The primary paper, the media article and the site appraisal provide different accounts of the same underlying study. This is a bounded answer about the reported denominator. A corrected source table or a participant-level record inconsistent with the published counts would justify revisiting it.

## 7 · Handoff and Review

- Follow-up: [worked gap card on reconstruction and comparison](https://akashicnet.org/downloads/akashicomni-worked-gap-nde-mapping.md).
- Review history: v1, 11 November 2026. Prepared for the public teaching workflow. Independent methodological review pending.
- Sharing: the example uses public passages and published aggregate counts. Any reuse of participant drawings or individual records would need its own rights and consent check.
