{"checked_on":"2026-11-06","scope":"Targeted full-text technical appraisal; selected equations and assumptions, not every appendix or independent peer review","papers":[{"key":"almheiri-review","version":"2006.06872v1","sections":"§§4–6,9–11.2","source":"https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.93.035002","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"18f366bdcae620b86cbf99ec6df8c1e5d617d51804de690dd4f399d104811553"},{"key":"miyata-2026","version":"2602.01241v1","sections":"§§2.1,2.7,3.1,3.4,4","source":"https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP08(2026)068","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"925ed25cbfe7da1f03c67e46e26d3cbf8e1a01d511ed688e71a3ad55b2225b41"},{"key":"hergott-2026","version":"2505.15096v2","sections":"§§II–III","source":"https://doi.org/10.1103/8m7g-zz3k","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"83c23be57f7b3525e155858a389d777b7086ad2283314ad2437d4f337c170fc5"},{"key":"du-2026","version":"2510.11921v2","sections":"§§II–V","source":"https://doi.org/10.1103/b1my-3v4r","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"a9d5b8b7710646f588b2cfc6e5c990f1b0569402bcaf08098ed08646fe37847c"},{"key":"bianchi-2026-v2","version":"2605.03922v2","sections":"§§II,IV–V,VII","source":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.03922v2","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"a4dcfc95eea4ba526f1f12a03df0c8ea6f9be0ea1b28269b0d1e2d08f1463358"},{"key":"qmm-2024","version":"publisher PDF via INSPIRE","sections":"§§2–3, especially 2.1.1 Eq3","source":"https://doi.org/10.3390/e26121039","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"b4e9d5ac96f3d90e8c5d664205889cd17a95c54d3eb664b7ea94d583498398df"},{"key":"nomura-2019","version":"1810.09453v4","sections":"§§3,5","source":"https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.99.086004","retrieved_pdf_sha256":"59ea7a1427cef3f4269bf2552972380de478a3717725786bb305feaaba309683"},{"key":"hawking-1976","version":"Scanned reprint, Hawking on the Big Bang and Black Holes, book pp112–125; original pp2460–2473","source":"https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.14.2460","scan_source":"https://teachmint.storage.googleapis.com/public/858758408/StudyMaterial/b5f8aad3-5be9-4c75-aeb3-84414dacf777.pdf","sections":"Selected central argument: p2463, §§II–III, pair-state discussion §IV and §V; formulas pp2463,2467,2472 visually inspected","collected_pdf_sha256":"ada9fce7764baa21214955bef170f02419ca55fdaa061cfeb7c0aac72b34202c","extracted_reprint_sha256":"1c6e55367a579afc277afa2ef36b54a98a4a32dc797473c5feacd8b114f99698","limitations":"Third-party scan not certified against publisher master; original full integral derivations not independently reproduced; no copyrighted PDF redistributed"}],"barriers":["Publisher and harvest endpoints denied access; targeted original-paper reading completed through the recorded reprint","Three additional MDPI full texts rate-limited; PMC verification screens","Liu 2025 main text subscription-restricted"],"audit_script_sha256":"185c8a99e13cab517a6b1f8c575fe43bb058133887cfd181bc7081488f7bb5b7","foundations_audit_script_sha256":"31a98d9024647e4677ada53f2f523331fd253082f9cb5b1302a0f2de555cd384","editorial_review_checked_on":"2026-11-11","editorial_status":"under_editorial_review","anniversary_target":{"date":"2026-11-15","status":"provisional","basis":"APS publication date 15 November 1976"},"editorial_reviews":[{"checked_on":"2026-11-11","scope":"Historical framing and evidence-state corrections; not an exhaustive fresh appraisal of every model or a hardware replication","sources":[{"key":"hawking-1976-metadata","source":"https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.14.2460","access":"APS abstract and publication record; central argument checked through third-party reprint text with imperfect OCR. Publisher PDF inaccessible."},{"key":"hawking-2005","source":"https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.72.084013","author_manuscript":"https://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-th/0507171","version":"hep-th/0507171v2","sections":"III–VI","publication_date":"2005-10-18","access":"APS publication record and full author manuscript inspected; no new proof of the path-integral argument claimed"},{"key":"qmm-2026","source":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s11128-026-05292-0","access":"Publisher text; basis-level retrieval metric distinguished from tomographic state fidelity"}],"applied_corrections":["Prominent 1976-to-2005 comparison","Pure states also have density matrices","Separate entropy calculations from state reconstruction","Minimum time required for purification; May preprint revised 26 October","Reconcile original-paper access notes"],"hardware_execution":"pending","independent_reproduction":"pending","publication_approval":false}]}