Planned Supporting Module · Review & Accountability Module
AkashicAUDIT
The Review Desk
Review whether claims, sources, checks and publication decisions meet the criteria declared for a piece of work.
Planned · Definition Draft · v0.1.0-draft.3 · Readiness Unassessed
What It Would Receive and Produce
A Practical Example
Before sharing a case study, check whether the account is represented fairly, the sources support each material claim, limitations are visible and actual tests are distinguished from proposals.
This is an illustration of the proposed method. It is not a completed case study or test result.
How It Connects
AkashicTEST supplies actual check results; AkashicTRACE supplies the source trail; AkashicSTATE records component readiness. AUDIT is proposed to review those records against stated criteria.
AkashicTEST · AkashicTRACE · AkashicSTATE · AkashicFOOTPRINT
Proposed Handoff
Link review findings, corrections and rechecks to AkashicLEDGER so their history can be retained. This handoff requires future implementation.
Draft Guidance
Use this as a human checklist or copy it into your chosen assistant. Add material within its authorised scope.
Use this planned AkashicAUDIT checklist. Record the scope, criteria, reviewer role and authorised audience. Link each finding to a source, claim or check record. Separate passed, failed, untested and reasoned not-applicable checks. Record severity with reasons, a proposed correction and the method for rechecking it. State whether review was by the original author or an independent reviewer. Keep Restricted and HOLD material within its existing audience. Return findings, evidence, changes needed and open questions. For each material claim, compare it with the exact source excerpt and choose supported, partly supported, contradicted or unresolved, with a reason. Split compound claims and check numbers, dates, population, qualifiers and causal language. Record evidence availability separately; absent or irrelevant evidence does not establish falsity. Include a check ID, exact source pointer, expected and observed result where a test has a declared expectation, observation timestamp, reviewer role and scope limits. Preserve the prior decision when revising it. Declare the reviewed edition, selection method and coverage: eligible, reviewed and excluded items with exclusion reasons. Do not imply unreviewed items passed. Give findings stable IDs and keep severity separate from confidence. Use open, correction proposed, awaiting recheck, closed or accepted risk states. Close only after the declared recheck passes on the revised edition and evidence is linked. An accepted risk remains distinct from a passed check; name the decision owner and reason. Preserve disagreements, both rationales and any adjudication; original-author review is never independent validation. Record what each check can establish and its limits. Escalate inaccessible evidence or unresolved material contradictions to a publication decision, preserving HOLD until the authorised decision owner resolves it. Public summaries use public evidence only; keep restricted source metadata within its authorised boundary. MATERIAL: [Add the authorised records and question.]
AkashicSTATE · 19 November 2026
State and Development Boundary
- Category
- Planned Supporting Modules
- Type
- Review & Accountability Module
- Edition
- v0.1.0-draft.3
- Release Stage
- Planned · Definition Draft
- Readiness
- Unassessed · no score assigned
- Meta / Mettā
- Unassessed / Unassessed
- Visibility
- Public definition. Restricted operational records and source metadata remain within the owner-only sandbox. HOLD stays visible.
Integration record: Editorial integration decision recorded 19 November 2026: add AUDIT and LEDGER as planned supporting modules, separately from the 18-component Bronze snapshot.
Next evidence: Agree a bounded protocol, try representative cases, compare reviewers and record disagreements, missed issues and introduced errors.
Storage, automatic integration and enforcement remain planned. Existing component versions and readiness ratings are unchanged.
First Recorded Checklist Trial · 19 November 2026
AUDIT and LEDGER in Practice
NEXUS-AUDIT-LEDGER-PILOT-001 reviews this pair’s published definitions, state labels and discovery links. It links source checks to the preceding release’s browser observations and confirmed deployment receipt, then records the integration, publication and trial as dated events.
The implementing assistant performed this review. Independent comparison, durable storage and access-control testing remain open. Both modules stay planned and unassessed.
Second Recorded Trial · 19 November 2026
Known Errors, Clean Cases and One Miss
NEXUS-AUDIT-LEDGER-PILOT-002 ran four explicit rules on nine synthetic cases. Of nine deliberately included defect instances, eight were caught and one was missed. No false alarms occurred in this small set. Eight of nine cases matched their declared expectations.
The missed case supplied an unrelated excerpt: checking that evidence exists did not establish that it supports the claim. The full detection target was not met. Five structured defect cases were identified; the semantic mismatch was missed; three negative cases remained unflagged.
This is a non-blind rule-assisted checklist trial written and run by the implementing assistant. It is not an independent AI benchmark, a real website permission test or evidence of general accuracy. Both modules remain planned and unassessed. Pilot 001 is preserved unchanged.
Read the Cases, Expected and Observed Results and Linked Events
AkashicAUDIT · v0.1.0-draft.3
Does the Source Support the Claim?
Assess the claim against the supplied excerpt, within its scope. Record evidence availability separately from support. This is a human or assistant checklist; no automatic semantic classifier is deployed.
| Outcome | Use When |
|---|---|
| Supported | The excerpt supports all material parts within matching scope and certainty. |
| Partly Supported | Some material parts are supported; others are absent or overextended, with no explicit material contradiction. |
| Contradicted | The excerpt explicitly conflicts with a material part. Quote or identify the conflict. |
| Unresolved | The evidence is unavailable, irrelevant, ambiguous or cannot establish the inference. Missing support alone does not prove falsity. |
Record a check ID, exact claim and source pointer, excerpt, availability, outcome, reason, timestamp, reviewer role and limitations. Split compound claims. Check numbers, dates, population, qualifiers and causal language. Retain earlier decisions when making corrections.
Pilot 003 · 19 November 2026
Four Outcomes and a Frozen Example Set
Twelve new synthetic claim–source pairs were frozen with their rubric and answer key before review results were recorded. All twelve assistant judgements matched the self-authored labels. The earlier unrelated-excerpt case was separately reviewed as unresolved.
The same assistant authored the examples, key and review. This is a worked rubric exercise, not a blind or independent accuracy benchmark. Its results cannot establish improvement over Pilot 002. A separate reviewer’s comparison remains pending. Both modules remain planned and unassessed.
Pilots 001 and 002 are preserved. The new record also documents that Pilot 002’s ninth case was added after its initial eight-case run.
Read the Frozen Inputs, Reasons, Scores and Event History · Separate Reviewer Packet Without Answers
AkashicENHANCE Review · 19 November 2026
From Finding to Verified Closure
The checklist now declares coverage, separates severity from confidence and records reviewer disagreements. A correction remains awaiting recheck until the declared check passes on the revised edition with linked evidence. Accepted risk is a separate decision, with an owner and reason.
| Record | Required Detail |
|---|---|
| Coverage | Reviewed edition, selection method, eligible and reviewed items and exclusions with reasons. Unreviewed items have no pass. |
| Finding | Stable ID, criterion, evidence, severity with reason, confidence, action owner and proposed correction. |
| Recheck | Method, expected and observed result, revised edition, date, reviewer and evidence link. |
| Decision | Open, correction proposed, awaiting recheck, closed or accepted risk. Preserve earlier decisions and unresolved disagreements. |
This is a guidance revision and a public editorial record. It does not implement a workflow engine, automatic enforcement, protected storage or independent validation. AkashicAUDIT remains planned and unassessed. Pilots 001–003 are preserved.
Read the Findings, Before-and-After Changes and Rechecks · AkashicENHANCE
